A Review of Anthony Browne’s Psychological Picture Book: The Ultimate Guide to Facing and Overcoming Anxiety

Sil­ly Bil­ly (Chi­nese edi­tion), CITIC Press, 2025

British pic­ture book mas­ter Antho­ny Browne not only won the Hans Chris­t­ian Ander­sen Award, often referred to as the “Lit­tle Nobel Prize,” in 2002, but also con­tin­ued to hone his writ­ing skills and expand his cre­ative hori­zons. This has earned him count­less fans among the gen­er­al pub­lic and made him a lead­ing fig­ure in his pro­fes­sion­al field. In Octo­ber 2024, Mar­tin Bas­sett, a pop­u­lar pic­ture book artist in Ger­many, vis­it­ed Bei­jing. Dur­ing our con­ver­sa­tion, I men­tioned that I admire Antho­ny Browne and have trans­lat­ed more than 20 of his books. Mar­tin imme­di­ate­ly exclaimed excit­ed­ly, “Antho­ny Browne is my hero!”“

​​This book, “Bil­ly the Wor­ry­ing,” is one I’ve been fol­low­ing for a long time. I recent­ly had the priv­i­lege of trans­lat­ing it, and I’m hap­py to have the oppor­tu­ni­ty to share my spe­cial fond­ness for it.

Antho­ny’s “Psy­cho­log­i­cal Pic­ture Book”“

Of the approx­i­mate­ly 50 pic­ture books Antho­ny Browne cre­at­ed over near­ly half a cen­tu­ry, *Bil­ly the Wor­ry­ing* can be broad­ly cat­e­go­rized as part of his “psy­cho­log­i­cal pic­ture books.” While these books also tell fun sto­ries through text and illus­tra­tions, they often focus on psy­cho­log­i­cal growth. For exam­ple, his Willy the Chim­panzee series, includ­ing *Willie the Cow­ard*, *Willie the Hero*, *Willie and Friends*, and *Willie the Magi­cian*, are all enter­tain­ing sto­ries that actu­al­ly explore psy­cho­log­i­cal issues in chil­dren’s devel­op­ment, such as bul­ly­ing and timid­i­ty, infe­ri­or­i­ty and self-accep­tance, dif­fer­ences and inter­ac­tion, friend­ship and mutu­al sup­port, and so on. *Willie and a Cloud* explores how to over­come anx­i­ety and depres­sion; *Joe’s First Par­ty* depicts chil­dren’s emo­tion­al strug­gles with the unknown; *How Are You Feel­ing?* deals with rec­og­niz­ing emo­tions; and *Kai’s Home Is Dif­fer­ent* tells the sto­ry of the old­er child’s psy­cho­log­i­cal reac­tions to the impend­ing change in a fam­i­ly with two chil­dren.

Cov­er of “Willie and a Cloud”
Inte­ri­or pages of “Bil­ly the Wor­ry­ing Man”

Antho­ny’s sig­na­ture sur­re­al­ist style skill­ful­ly blends real­i­ty and imag­i­na­tion, con­cretiz­ing abstract emo­tions and psy­cho­log­i­cal states with tan­gi­ble visu­al forms. This approach is par­tic­u­lar­ly suit­able for explor­ing chil­dren’s emo­tions and psy­cho­log­i­cal top­ics because, through dis­tort­ed, anthro­po­mor­phic, and sym­bol­ic imagery, hid­den emo­tions can be visu­al­ized, pro­vid­ing a path­way to under­stand­ing com­plex psy­chol­o­gy. It also cre­ates a safe space for chil­dren to express them­selves, stim­u­lat­ing their res­o­nance and expand­ing their imag­i­na­tion, there­by at least achiev­ing the func­tion of iden­ti­fy­ing emo­tions and poten­tial­ly offer­ing com­fort or heal­ing. The first edi­tion of *Bil­ly the Wor­ry­ing* in 2006 is an out­stand­ing exam­ple of his unique approach to psy­cho­log­i­cal heal­ing through pic­ture books.

Unique tips for fac­ing anx­i­ety

Bil­ly in the book is a lit­tle boy who used to wor­ry about every­thing. This kind of char­ac­ter is not uncom­mon in con­tem­po­rary chil­dren’s pic­ture books. Chi­nese read­ers may be more famil­iar with Kevin Han­ks’ “I’m So Wor­ried,” first pub­lished in 2010. In that book, the most wor­ried char­ac­ter is a lit­tle girl named Lily, and her anx­i­ety is alle­vi­at­ed through mak­ing friends, a friend­ly envi­ron­ment, and sup­port. How­ev­er, “Bil­ly the Wor­ry­er” uses more visu­al­ly strik­ing sur­re­al­ist imagery to present anx­i­ety itself, guid­ing chil­dren to con­front and over­come anx­i­ety through sym­bol­ic meth­ods and autonomous growth.

Inte­ri­or pages of “Bil­ly the Wor­ry­ing Man”
In “Play­ing with Shapes,” Antho­ny dis­cuss­es his child­hood and anx­i­eties.

At the begin­ning, the pro­tag­o­nist Bil­ly is plagued by anx­i­ety, to the point that it keeps him awake at night. Whether it’s a hat, shoes, clouds and rain, or even a giant bird that appears out of nowhere, Bil­ly is con­stant­ly wor­ried. This anx­i­ety is ubiq­ui­tous, real­is­ti­cal­ly reflect­ing the emo­tion­al strug­gles many chil­dren face as they grow up. Brown brings these abstract anx­i­eties to life through vivid lan­guage and illus­tra­tions, allow­ing chil­dren to clear­ly rec­og­nize and per­ceive them.

Inte­ri­or pages of “Bil­ly the Wor­ry­ing Man”

Bil­ly’s turn­ing point came from his grand­moth­er. She intro­duced him to the tra­di­tion of wor­ry dolls: telling these tiny dolls about your wor­ries and plac­ing them under your pil­low, where the dolls would wor­ry for you at night. This tra­di­tion from Guatemala in Cen­tral Amer­i­ca pro­vides a sym­bol­ic way of trans­fer­ring emo­tions by giv­ing chil­dren a tan­gi­ble tool. After try­ing it, Bil­ly found him­self sleep­ing sound­ly; this sim­ple yet effec­tive heal­ing pow­er was com­fort­ing.

The pow­er of free­dom beyond anx­i­ety

Antho­ny Browne’s bril­liance lies in not let­ting the sto­ry stop at Bil­ly over­com­ing his anx­i­ety. As the plot unfolds, Bil­ly grad­u­al­ly real­izes that he has entrust­ed all his wor­ries to the wor­ry dolls, and won­ders if these dolls will become over­ly wor­ried as a result. This reverse anx­i­ety, seem­ing­ly humor­ous, actu­al­ly reflects a pro­found human con­cern:Tran­scend your anx­i­ety about your­self and start think­ing about oth­ers.

Inte­ri­or pages of “Bil­ly the Wor­ry­ing Man”

​​The cli­max of the sto­ry lies in Bil­ly’s actions. He decides to make more “wor­ry dolls” to alle­vi­ate their “bur­den.” This twist is not only cap­ti­vat­ing in terms of plot but also ele­vates the theme. From sim­ple emo­tion­al man­age­ment to car­ing for oth­ers, Antho­ny con­veys a par­tic­u­lar­ly pos­i­tive and benev­o­lent val­ue through Bil­ly’s growth. This process of tran­scend­ing anx­i­ety and turn­ing to care is high­ly inspir­ing for both chil­dren and adults. Such a work not only con­veys unique secrets to emo­tion­al man­age­ment but also teach­es us, in a gen­tle yet pro­found way, how to find strength in anx­i­ety and use that strength to care for and help oth­ers.

Antho­ny’s ele­vat­ing treat­ment of anx­i­ety reminds me of Dan­ish philoso­pher Kierkegaard’s *The Con­cept of Anx­i­ety*.Fear and Trem­blingThe view­points expressed in the text can be broad­ly sum­ma­rized as fol­lows:Anx­i­ety is a defin­ing char­ac­ter­is­tic of human nature; it is pre­cise­ly through anx­i­ety that we expe­ri­ence our free­dom. Anx­i­ety is, in fact, syn­ony­mous with pos­si­bil­i­ty.This philoso­pher said, “Anx­i­ety is not found in wild ani­mals because they lack the essen­tial char­ac­ter­is­tics of the mind.” There­fore, we, as human beings, should be proud of our abil­i­ty to feel anx­i­ety. Anx­i­ety is not sim­ply fear, but an aware­ness of free­dom. Free­dom is accom­pa­nied by anx­i­ety because free­dom means fac­ing choic­es and tak­ing respon­si­bil­i­ty.

Sto­ries orig­i­nat­ing from per­son­al life

Play­ing the Shape Game

If you’ve read Antho­ny’s auto­bi­og­ra­phy, *Play­ing with Shapes*, you’ll know that this pic­ture book mas­ter had a par­tic­u­lar­ly anx­ious (wor­ried) nature from a young age, a trait inher­it­ed from his Brown fam­i­ly. Antho­ny recalled his child­hood, say­ing:““I’m a some­what neu­rot­ic lit­tle boy. I can’t fall asleep with­out thor­ough­ly check­ing my clos­et and under my bed before going to sleep.””The strange wall­pa­per pat­terns in Bil­ly’s bed­room that read­ers see in “Bil­ly the Wor­ry­ing Man” actu­al­ly orig­i­nate from Antho­ny’s child­hood mem­o­ries. Even as an adult, his ten­den­cy to wor­ry per­sist­ed, and he repeat­ed­ly recounts his var­i­ous anx­ious expe­ri­ences in his auto­bi­og­ra­phy, prov­ing that he was the per­fect choice to cre­ate works explor­ing the psy­chol­o­gy of anx­i­ety.

How­ev­er, com­pared to his moth­er’s extreme lev­el of anx­i­ety, Antho­ny’s anx­i­ety lev­el pales in com­par­i­son. His fam­i­ly con­sist­ed of his par­ents and two broth­ers. His moth­er, the only woman in the fam­i­ly, was always spe­cial­ly pro­tect­ed; Antho­ny and his broth­er Michael affec­tion­ate­ly called her “our Doris.” When their father was alive, he often trav­eled for work, some­times return­ing home very late. In these sit­u­a­tions, “our Doris and Michael would chat­ter on and on. They wor­ried that Dad might have been in a car acci­dent and died. But I nev­er wor­ried along with them…” (from *Play­ing with Shapes*, here­inafter the same). This shows that Michael was more prone to wor­ry than Antho­ny.

A child­hood pho­to of Antho­ny Browne with his broth­er, par­ents, and oth­er fam­i­ly mem­bers.
Antho­ny Browne’s child­hood fam­i­ly por­trait drawn in his auto­bi­og­ra­phy

Antho­ny stat­ed with cer­tain­ty that the main pro­to­type for “Bil­ly the Wor­ry­ing” was “our Doris.” It all start­ed when, dur­ing a trip around the world shar­ing his cre­ative insights, he received a gift of “wor­ry dolls” in Mexico—a box of ten bright­ly col­ored dolls. Upon return­ing home, he gave them to some­one who need­ed them more: “the most wor­ri­some per­son I’ve ever known—my moth­er.” Sure enough, his moth­er loved the dolls, and they did help alle­vi­ate her anx­i­ety for the first few days. But one morn­ing, Antho­ny dis­cov­ered his moth­er was caught up in a new wor­ry: she had “lost the wor­ry dolls!”

Antho­ny did­n’t adopt the moth­er’s new wor­ry in the sto­ry, but instead cre­at­ed a new approach for Bil­ly to imple­ment. This new approach still stemmed from his obser­va­tion and under­stand­ing of his moth­er: “Her wor­ry is most unique in that she always wor­ries about oth­ers. Our Doris proves that wor­ry and con­cern are very close­ly relat­ed. I think that when wor­ry turns into con­cern, it means that a per­son­’s emo­tions have reached a cer­tain matu­ri­ty.” Through the growth of the young boy Bil­ly in his wor­ries, learn­ing to trans­form his own wor­ries into con­cern for oth­ers, Antho­ny con­veys a very impor­tant mes­sage: “Every­one wor­ries, but only the kind­est peo­ple can trans­form their wor­ries into con­cern for oth­ers.” —For this rea­son, I’m will­ing to see *Bil­ly the Wor­ry­er* as an “upgrad­ed” ver­sion of Antho­ny’s unique secret to man­ag­ing anx­i­ety.

Bil­ly is Willie

As a mas­ter of pic­ture books, Antho­ny Browne’s visu­al sto­ry­telling in this book is also excep­tion­al. He con­tin­ues his sur­re­al­ist approach to explor­ing psy­cho­log­i­cal phe­nom­e­na. The illus­tra­tions con­cretize Bil­ly’s anx­i­ety: a huge dark cloud loom­ing over the bed, damp rain beside the bed, and a giant bird fly­ing around the room. These visu­al­ly strik­ing images direct­ly present Bil­ly’s inner fears. This visu­al expres­sion not only deep­ens the emo­tion­al ten­sion of the sto­ry but also helps read­ers (espe­cial­ly chil­dren) to under­stand the abstract emo­tion of anx­i­ety more con­crete­ly.

Inte­ri­or pages of “Bil­ly the Wor­ry­ing Man”

As Bil­ly begins to accept the help of the Wor­ry Dolls, the col­ors and atmos­phere of the imagery grad­u­al­ly change. Dark, somber scenes are replaced by warm, bright tones, metaphor­i­cal­ly rep­re­sent­ing Bil­ly’s emo­tion­al shift. Espe­cial­ly at the end, when Bil­ly cre­ates a large group of Wor­ry Dolls, the imagery is filled with col­or and vital­i­ty, sym­bol­iz­ing the clar­i­ty of Bil­ly’s inner world and the joy of his growth.

The author’s self-nar­ra­tion in “Play­ing with Shapes”

It’s worth men­tion­ing that when Antho­ny was draft­ing the sto­ry, he actu­al­ly envi­sioned Willie the chim­panzee as the pro­tag­o­nist. Among the pic­ture book char­ac­ters he cre­at­ed, Willie was the most relat­able to young read­ers, with many chil­dren see­ing them­selves in him. How­ev­er, the pub­lish­er’s edi­tor, Denise, loved the sto­ry so much that she felt Willie was already deeply ingrained in the pub­lic con­scious­ness, and adding anoth­er “sil­ly Willie” would seem like mere­ly fill­ing in a sequel, sig­nif­i­cant­ly dimin­ish­ing the book’s unique val­ue. Antho­ny read­i­ly agreed, and after care­ful con­sid­er­a­tion and sev­er­al attempts, ulti­mate­ly adopt­ed the image of a lit­tle boy, Bil­ly, but Bil­ly dressed the same as Willie, had the same hair­style, and even walked with the same hunched back. He lat­er recalled:““In my opin­ion, Bil­ly and Willy are inter­change­able. I con­sid­er ‘Bil­ly the Wor­ry­ing’ to be a book in the Willy series, just with a dif­fer­ent title.””

The author’s self-nar­ra­tion in “Play­ing with Shapes”

“Bil­ly the Wor­ry­ing Child” is indeed a very spe­cial work by Antho­ny Browne, bear­ing the imprint of his per­son­al life and fam­i­ly mem­o­ries, while also being a heal­ing work that attempts to help chil­dren con­front anx­i­ety. Through the fas­ci­nat­ing tra­di­tions and cus­toms of Cen­tral Amer­i­can chil­dren and Bil­ly’s com­ing-of-age sto­ry, it show­cas­es a unique wis­dom of tran­scend­ing the self and car­ing for oth­ers. He skill­ful­ly blends psy­cho­log­i­cal insights with sur­re­al­ist artis­tic expres­sion, demon­strat­ing the pecu­liar mag­ic of draw­ing strength from anx­i­ety, which is also quite inspir­ing for adult read­ers.

Writ­ten by A‑Jia on Decem­ber 12, 2024 in Bei­jing

Cov­er of the Eng­lish edi­tion of “Bil­ly the Wor­ry­ing”

​​​​