【Ten-fold Formula】
Sing, recite, speak, act, draw, perform, eat, break, chat, and think.
【Special Note】
Each word in the Cross Formula represents a type of gameplay. They are just some common ones and do not cover all. In addition, it does not mean that every book is suitable for all kinds of gameplay, nor does it mean that everyone is suitable for all kinds of gameplay. They are more like an inspiring example. Everyone can use the appropriate book and adopt the appropriate gameplay according to their own strengths. In addition, these gameplays are not designed specifically for children. Adults can play with them if they want. Real good “mud” is loved by both adults and children.
【Detailed Explanation of the Cross Formula】
(1) Speaking
1. Sing: Some picture books can be sung, or they themselves have lyrics or contain lyrics, such as Su Wu Shepherding Sheep, Five Little
Ducks, We’re Going on a Bear
Hunt (“We Go Bear Hunting”); to be more broad, we should include nursery rhymes, such as “A Garden of Vegetables Became a Spirit” and “The Mouse Gets a Bride”; or the story in the book comes from a song, such as “Joseph Has an Old Coat”, or a poem that can be chanted, such as “Dawn”; or the folk tale itself has a familiar song, such as “Pulling the Carrot” and “Little Red Riding Hood”; and even more amazing is that when the storyteller is in the mood, he will improvise a tune based on the text of the picture book and sing it. For example, I have heard the storyteller sing “The Missing Piece”, which is great.
2. Reading: With the exception of wordless books, almost any picture book can be read. Having the audience look at the pictures while the storyteller reads the words (reading aloud or reading aloud) is the simplest and most effective way to engage with the story. Sometimes, we find some books difficult to read. The reasons are: ① We’re not ready; ② The text in the picture book is simply not good (not suitable for reading); ③ Or, they simply don’t fit the audience.
Almost everyone who can read can read, so people often underestimate this “reading” method. However, in my opinion, it’s the most advanced of all the ways to play with picture books (I intentionally omitted “one of”). A true master should be able to read right away, acting as a special listener, observing the pictures and listening to the sounds (their own) alongside others, entering the authentic world of the picture book story. This requires diligent study, diligent reading, and contemplation, and, of course, a genuine love for the book.
3. Speaking: Some picture books require discussion, such as wordless books. But there are many other picture books that deserve discussion beyond just reading. For example, books like “Su Wu Shepherding Sheep” and “Peking Opera Cats” are difficult for listeners to understand without some discussion, as the cultural context is inevitably unfamiliar to young listeners. Other storytellers are highly skilled, and they might need to include a punchline or a splendid musical flourish during their storytelling, which is also fine. However, in these cases, the picture book in hand is merely a supporting medium. If the picture book is the main character, the storyteller needs to somewhat suppress their talent and be more restrained.
The “telling” here is different from “chatting”. It mainly refers to telling stories apart from the text of the picture book, while “chatting” means talking beyond the story.
(2) Hands-on
4. Do: This mnemonic word “do” encompasses a wide range of activities, encompassing anything that requires hands-on interaction rather than drawing, acting, or eating. This includes crafts, games, exercise, and so on. While it may seem like a way to entertain a picture book, engaging in this activity can also be beneficial to understanding the book. For example, after reading “The Flower Granny,” you might plant flowers; after reading “Pulling the Radish,” you might play tug-of-war; after reading “The Little Black Fish,” you might play music games; after reading “A Garden of Green Vegetables Becomes a Spirit,” you might stroll the vegetable garden or form groups to play war games. Many storytellers, especially teachers, have been quite creative in this area, such as Teacher Fang Suzhen’s handmade books, which are truly exceptional. Appropriately applied, reading can transform into a truly engaging game.
5. Paintings: Excellent picture books are like art galleries on paper, allowing readers to not only appreciate masterpieces from a wide range of styles and cultural backgrounds but also naturally inspire some to take up their own brushes. However, it’s important to understand that the images in picture books are primarily used to convey stories and emotions. Therefore, for young readers, the most inspiring creative impulses are often not those that adults consider ornate, but rather simple, unpretentious, and straightforward works, such as “Miffy,” “Rainbow Flowers,” “Happy Birthday, Moon!”, “The Very Hungry Caterpillar,” “The Very Hungry Snake,” and “Plaid Elephant.”
6. Acting: Picture books with characters are generally playable. The simplest way to act out the story is to read it aloud in different roles, such as “Crocodile is Afraid of the Dentist” and “The Giving Tree.” However, it’s even more fun to add props. The recently released “Pigsy and the Big Bad Wolf” includes masks for acting out, which is quite thoughtful. However, if readers are willing to put in a little effort and incorporate the “do” principle, they can also make their own interesting masks or puppets to act out the story.
A bit of advice from experience: if you are in kindergarten or school, it is suitable to choose stories with many characters and vivid images, such as “The Gruffalo”, “The Bremen Musicians”, “I Choose Myself”, “Who Pulled on My Head”, and “Duck on a Bicycle”. Occasionally, you can also choose stories with fewer characters, but it is best to take turns to perform, such as “True Friends”.
7. Eating: This is the most creative activity, as there are plenty of picture books about food, but few actually teach you how to eat. You’ll need to come up with your own ideas. For example, after reading “Green Eggs and Ham,” you might just want to try making a dish. Or “Cloud Bread”—bread is easy, clouds are hard to come by! You can also try “Stone Soup” or “Angry Soup.” And after reading “Zi’er, Tutu,” try using papaya or watermelon. Some picture books even have recipes, like “Apple Pancakes” from “Passy the Rabbit,” and the recently released “Mrs. Moffrey’s Monster,” which has a cake recipe. The recipes in “Gulley and Gula” are pretty much fairytale recipes.
(3) Brain Training
8. Deciphering: This seemingly most technical approach is suitable for readers who enjoy technical and detective games. “Deciphering” means cracking or solving a mystery. Some picture books truly require deciphering to be enjoyable, such as Anthony Browne’s works, which are almost all richly detailed. Without deciphering works like “Gorilla,” “My Father,” and “Voices,” the fun would be greatly diminished. The purpose of deciphering a picture book is primarily to uncover the story hidden beneath the surface, not to develop divergent or extended associations. For example, consider the story of the tiger cart and the frog in Janosz’s “Hello, Little Pig!”, the story of the ant wearing a hat in “The Ant and the Watermelon,” and the story of the mouse family in “Grandpa Will Find a Way.” There are also deeper stories, such as the more metaphorical ones in “In the Forest.” Peng Yi’s “Picture Books: Reading and Classics” focuses on the joy of deciphering picture books.
Studying picture books requires a spirit of “breaking”. The most persistent person in this regard is Professor Nordman of Canada. He once wrote a poem for the first page of the book “Going on a River with Uncle Gam” (which read “This
is Mr.
Gumpy” (literally “This is Mr. Gumpy”, translated into Chinese as “He is Uncle Gump”). David Lewis from the UK is also quite capable, having written an 11-page essay on “Oops, Little Red Riding Hood”. And there is Jane Dunant, whose book “Seeing the Pictures in Picture Books” mainly analyzes two books: “The Lamb Could Not Sleep” and “A Cloudy Day”.
However, I think it is necessary to remind you that although “breaking” is very professional and fun, it can also lead to “obsession”, so be careful!
9. Chat: This seems like the easiest way to engage in conversation, and it’s actually the most common method used in daily life. Of course, it’s often not used effectively. For example, even though it’s a very interesting story, it’s tempting to chase the child with questions like: How many goats, wolves, piglets, and hunters are there in the story? What clothes did the wolves wear? What did the goats say? What did the hunters do? And what moral does this story teach us? … This kind of conversation is worse than not engaging in conversation at all. Therefore, Taiwan’s “Little Big Reading Club” specifically advocates “reading the words when there are words, and quietly flipping through the book when there are no words.” This is probably intended to prevent this kind of boring book talk.
How to talk about books with children? This is a profound subject. Chambers once wrote a book specifically titled “Talk About It,” the Chinese version of which is included in “Creating a Reading Environment for Children.” However, even if you’ve read the book, it doesn’t necessarily mean you’re ready to start a conversation. More importantly, we need to be genuinely interested in the book, just as interested as the child. If you haven’t done your homework and aren’t genuinely interested, it’s best not to discuss it. Of course, if you temporarily set aside the idea of “what moral this book is supposed to teach the child,” there’s nothing wrong with casual conversation. For example, if you read a book about wolves, you could talk about a story about a wolf that plagued your hometown in the mountains as a child… This might be a bit exaggerated, but the point is to make the conversation interesting and relevant to your own life.
10. Think: Associating, imagining, letting your imagination run wild… This is the most personal way to play. Once, during a discussion about a book reading activity (obviously, no children were present), the topic somehow came up: “Little Mouse’s Vest.” A friend who studies philosophy excitedly said, “This book is about Lao Tzu’s philosophy: accepting whatever happens, isn’t it?” Everyone was stunned at the time, but on reflection, it made sense. Some might ask, “Can children understand this?” I would counter with, “Do adults really understand this?” In the realm of thought and imagination, if we don’t use adults as the standard, adults don’t have much advantage over children.
Allow enough time and space for the “ideas” of the picture book, and don’t set limits on the territory. This kind of play has endless possibilities.